COMPARISON OF SURGICAL VERSUS NON-SURGICAL MANAGEMENT OF MID-SHAFT CLAVICULAR FRACTURES
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.71000/xfnan022Keywords:
Bone Plates, Clavicle Fractures, Constant Score, Fracture Fixation, Midshaft Clavicle, Orthopedic Surgery, Shoulder FunctionAbstract
Background: Mid-shaft clavicle fractures represent a common orthopedic injury, comprising approximately 80–85% of all clavicle fractures and 2–5% of adult fractures. These injuries are frequently encountered in both trauma and sports-related settings. Although non-surgical management has long been the standard due to its simplicity and traditionally favorable outcomes, recent literature suggests that surgical fixation may offer improved functional recovery in displaced cases. However, consensus remains lacking regarding the most effective treatment modality for optimal shoulder function.
Objective: To compare the functional outcomes of surgical management versus non-surgical management of mid-shaft clavicle fractures using the Constant-Murley Shoulder Score at three months.
Methods: This randomized controlled trial was conducted at the Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Benazir Bhutto Hospital, Rawalpindi, from April 15 to October 16, 2023. A total of 60 patients aged 18–80 years with displaced mid-shaft clavicle fractures were enrolled and randomized into two equal groups. Group A received non-surgical management with a figure-of-eight bandage and arm sling, while Group B underwent surgical fixation using plate osteosynthesis. Patients were followed up at three months, and functional outcomes were assessed using the Constant-Murley Shoulder Score. Data were analyzed using SPSS version 22, with a p-value ≤ 0.05 considered statistically significant.
Results: The mean time since injury was 3.67 ± 1.78 hours in the non-surgical group and 3.50 ± 1.55 hours in the surgical group (p = 0.701). At the third-month follow-up, the mean Constant score was significantly higher in the surgical group (77.23 ± 4.79) compared to the non-surgical group (68.97 ± 5.14), with a p-value < 0.001.
Conclusion: Surgical management of displaced mid-shaft clavicle fractures resulted in significantly better functional outcomes than non-surgical treatment when assessed at three months post-intervention.
References
Amer K, Smith B, Thomson JE, Congiusta D, Reilly MC, Sirkin MS, et al. Operative versus nonoperative outcomes of middle-third clavicle fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop Trauma 2020;34(1):e6-e13.
Sweet AA, Beks RB, IJpma FF, de Jong MB, Beeres FJ, Leenen LP, et al. Epidemiology of combined clavicle and rib fractures: a systematic review. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg 2022;48(5):3513-20.
Markes AR, Garcia-Lopez E, Halvorson RT, Swarup I. Management of displaced midshaft clavicle fractures in pediatrics and adolescents: operative vs nonoperative treatment. Orthop Res Rev 2022;14:373.
Whyte NS, Veerkamp MW, Parikh SN. Medial clavicle shaft fractures in children and adolescents: differences from adults and management. J Pediatr Orthop 2022;31(5):417-21.
Ramponi DR, Cerepani MJ. Clavicle fractures. Adv Emerg Nurs J 2021;43(2):123-7.
Murray NJ, Johnson T, Packham IN, Crowther MA, Chesser TJ. Reducing unnecessary fixation of midshaft clavicle fractures. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol 2022;32(7):1319-24.
Ju W-N, Cheng S, Qiao W-S, Qi B-C. Functional outcomes and adverse effects following three interventions for displaced midshaft clavicular fractures: A Bayesian network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res 2021;107(8):103066.
Qvist AH, Vaesel MT, Moss C, Jakobsen T, Jensen SL. No need to use both Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand and Constant-Murley score in studies of midshaft clavicular fractures. Acta Orthop 2020;91(6):789-93.
Myles P. More than just morbidity and mortality–quality of recovery and long‐term functional recovery after surgery. Anaesthesia 2020;75:e143-e50.
Maheshwari P, Peshin Sr C, Agarwal D. Functional Outcomes in Surgically Treated Clavicle Fractures: A Longitudinal Observational Study. Cureus 2023;15(10):e48081.
Yan MZ, Yuen W-s, Yeung S-c, Wing-Yin CW, Wong SC-y, Si-Qi WW, et al. Operative management of midshaft clavicle fractures demonstrates better long-term outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. PloS one 2022;17(4):e0267861.
Patel M, Heyworth BE, Dehghan N, Mehlman CT, McKee MD. Clavicular Fractures in the Adolescent. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023;105(9):713-23.
Han X, Zhang Y, Zhang X, Tan J. Comprehensive comparison between conservative therapy and surgical management for completely displaced and comminuted mid-shaft clavicle fractures. Int Orthop. 2024;48(7):1871-7.
Cornu O, Drissi Kaitouni M, Miri O, Moradi S, Manon J, Lambeau G, et al. Improved outcomes with surgical management of clavicular fractures? A retrospective study of matched pairs comparing conservative and surgical approach. Acta Orthop Belg. 2024;90(3):435-41.
Matsubara Y, Nakamura Y, Sasashige Y, Yokoya S, Adachi N. Long-term conservative treatment outcomes for midshaft clavicle fractures: a 10-to-30-year follow-up. J Orthop Surg Res. 2023;18(1):952.
Riiser MO, Molund M. Long-term Functional Outcomes and Complications in Operative Versus Nonoperative Treatment for Displaced Midshaft Clavicle Fractures in Adolescents: A Retrospective Comparative Study. J Pediatr Orthop. 2021;41(5):279-83.
Qvist AH, Væsel MT, Jensen CM, Jakobsen T, Jensen SL. Minimal Pain Decrease Between 2 and 4 Weeks After Nonoperative Management of a Displaced Midshaft Clavicle Fracture Is Associated with a High Risk of Symptomatic Nonunion. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021;479(1):129-38.
Sabatini CS, Edmonds EW, Nepple JJ, Liotta ES, Hergott K, Quinn M, et al. Nonoperative Versus Operative Treatment of Z-Type Comminuted Clavicle Fractures in Adolescents: A Prospective Substratified Cohort Analysis. J Orthop Trauma. 2024;38(7):351-7.
Wall KC, Reddy GB, Corrigan KL, Toth AP, Garrigues GE. Operative Versus Nonoperative Management of Displaced Midshaft Clavicle Fractures: A Cost-effectiveness Analysis. Orthopedics. 2022;45(5):e243-e51.
Sax OC, Monarrez R, Bains SS, Douglas SJ, Ingari JV. Operative Versus Nonoperative Treatment for Closed Displaced Midshaft Clavicle Fractures. Hand (N Y). 2024;19(2):294-9.
Hall JA, Schemitsch CE, Vicente MR, Dehghan N, Nauth A, Nowak LL, et al. Operative Versus Nonoperative Treatment of Acute Displaced Distal Clavicle Fractures: A Multicenter Randomized Controlled Trial. J Orthop Trauma. 2021;35(12):660-6.
Srinivasan A, Haque A, Kheiran A, Singh HP. Radiological and Long-Term Functional Outcomes of Displaced Distal Clavicle Fractures. J Orthop Trauma. 2023;37(2):89-95.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Saifullah, Obaid Ur Rahman (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
